ADP vs. Paylocity vs. Rippling: Which HR software is best

Between payroll complexities, compliance requirements, and workforce management, selecting the right HR software is a critical decision. ADP and Paylocity are established players in the space, but how do they actually compare — and is there a better alternative?

Both platforms promise to streamline your operations, but their approaches differ significantly. ADP targets enterprises with comprehensive global capabilities, while Paylocity focuses on mid-market businesses with strong domestic HR tools. Meanwhile, Rippling takes a fundamentally different approach by unifying HR, IT, and Finance in a single platform.

I've analyzed these three platforms through product documentation, user feedback, and hands-on research to understand their real-world performance.

In this guide, I'll cover:

• Core capabilities across payroll, talent management, and workforce tools

• How each platform handles integrations and scalability

• Real pricing structures and what drives costs

• Actual user experiences from verified review platforms

Quick comparison: ADP vs. Paylocity vs. Rippling at a glance

Before we dive into the details, here's how these three platforms measure up across key features:

Methodology: How we reviewed different payroll software

To give you an accurate comparison, I combined multiple research methods rather than relying on just one source.

• Product walkthroughs and documentation. I reviewed each platform's official documentation, feature lists, and product walkthroughs to verify capabilities and understand what's included in different packages. I also have access to Rippling as a user. 

• User reviews and feedback. I analyzed over 150 reviews on sites like G2, Capterra, and Software Advice to identify consistent patterns in what users love and what frustrates them. I focused on reviews from the past year to ensure the feedback reflects the current state of each platform.

Rippling editorial policy: Rippling puts our customers (and prospective customers!) first. The Rippling team is committed to providing information supported by product data, insights, and customer feedback to inform our content.

Features comparison: ADP vs. Paylocity vs. Rippling

After examining product capabilities and customer experiences, clear distinctions emerge. Let's explore where each platform excels and which best serves different business needs.

Payroll processing

Every HR platform starts with payroll. Here's how these three handle it.

Rippling

Rippling Payroll processes payroll for domestic and international workforces through a single unified system. The platform calculates taxes automatically, files with appropriate federal, state, and local agencies, and adjusts calculations when employees relocate.

The key differentiator is data flow. Payroll information doesn't just sit in one module; it instantly syncs across your financial systems, time tracking, benefits enrollment, and IT infrastructure. This eliminates duplicate data entry and minimizes human error.

Rippling supports payroll operations in 185+ countries with built-in local compliance, making it the only option in this comparison that handles international growth without requiring separate vendors or systems.

ADP

ADP delivers enterprise-grade global payroll with multi-currency processing and localized compliance frameworks in 140+ countries. The platform manages complex payroll scenarios spanning multiple jurisdictions, making it a solid option for established multinational corporations.

ADP allows flexible payroll scheduling — weekly, biweekly, monthly, or custom cadences — and integrates time data with payroll to calculate overtime automatically. Tax filing and regulatory monitoring help organizations stay current with evolving requirements.

However, ADP's breadth creates complexity. Multiple users report significant onboarding challenges, and the platform can overwhelm teams at smaller organizations without dedicated HR resources.

Paylocity

Paylocity delivers payroll processing with features including Everyday Pay (earned wage access), integrated expense management, and automated garnishment handling. The platform manages multi-state payroll effectively and recently expanded global capabilities through acquiring Blue Marble.

The system serves mid-market organizations well for standard payroll requirements. However, Paylocity's technical architecture depends on synchronized modules and third-party marketplace integrations rather than a unified underlying database, which can introduce delays when data moves between systems.

Our verdict

Rippling takes the lead for payroll processing, particularly for organizations needing global capabilities combined with seamless data flow across departments. ADP provides robust multinational payroll for large enterprises willing to navigate complexity, while Paylocity handles domestic and basic international payroll for mid-sized companies.

Talent and performance management

Effective performance management drives employee development and organizational alignment.

Rippling

Rippling’s performance management software delivers comprehensive talent management capabilities including 360-degree performance reviews, goal cascading, continuous feedback mechanisms, and calibration tools. The platform accommodates multiple review cycles simultaneously, offers customizable evaluation frameworks, and triggers automated workflows based on employee data points.

Because Rippling operates as a unified system, performance information connects directly to compensation planning, succession strategies, and learning assignments. This creates a complete view of employee growth without jumping between disconnected tools.

ADP

ADP provides an extensive talent management ecosystem encompassing recruiting, performance reviews, goal management, continuous feedback, and career pathing. The platform offers sophisticated tools for establishing development plans and tracking progress over time.

ADP's talent capabilities are particularly strong for large organizations with complex requirements. However, the system's complexity means smaller teams often struggle to fully leverage these features without substantial training investment.

Paylocity

Paylocity includes performance management functionality with review tools and development resources, but automation capabilities are more limited. Based on product documentation and user feedback, Paylocity cannot automatically assign mandatory training based on employee attributes or role changes — instead relying on notification reminders that require manual follow-up.

The platform provides solid performance tracking, but lacks Rippling's deep integration connecting performance data to compensation, succession planning, and automated learning paths.

Our verdict

Rippling delivers the most comprehensive talent management, especially when performance data automatically flows to succession planning and learning assignments. ADP offers strong enterprise-level capabilities with a steeper learning curve, while Paylocity serves mid-market performance management needs with some manual workarounds.

Learning management

Employee development depends on accessible training programs with clear tracking.

Rippling

Rippling's learning management system enables course creation, attribute-based training assignment, and automatic completion tracking. The platform handles diverse content formats including video, documents, SCORM packages, and interactive quizzes.

The automation sets Rippling's LMS apart. Training automatically assigns based on role, department, location, or any custom attribute you define. Integration with time & attendance means you can track learning hours for compliance requirements without manual timekeeping.

ADP

ADP supplies comprehensive LMS functionality with course authoring, extensive content libraries, and detailed compliance tracking. The platform supports multiple learning formats and provides robust reporting on training effectiveness and completion rates.

ADP's LMS connects well with its broader talent ecosystem, allowing organizations to link learning to performance outcomes and career progression. Setup and ongoing management require significant time investment, particularly for teams new to enterprise learning systems.

Paylocity

Paylocity offers learning management with course creation tools and training content options. However, automation is constrained — the system cannot automatically assign required training when employee attributes change or trigger learning workflows based on role transitions. Instead, administrators receive notifications but must manually assign courses and follow up on completions.

Our verdict

Rippling and ADP both deliver full-featured LMS capabilities with strong automation, while Paylocity requires more manual intervention. Rippling's advantage lies in automated assignments driven by employee data and seamless integration with systems like time tracking and performance management.

Benefits administration

Benefits impact every employee and demand both accuracy and usability.

Rippling

Rippling manages benefits administration through a unified interface where employees compare plan options and complete enrollment. The system accommodates medical, dental, vision, FSA, HSA, 401(k), and additional benefit categories.

With Rippling's unified architecture, benefits data automatically synchronizes with payroll deductions, employee records, and financial systems. Status changes — new hires, terminations, qualifying life events — trigger benefits adjustments without manual intervention.

Rippling also provides access to competitive benefits packages through its PEO service, giving small and mid-sized companies access to enterprise-quality benefits at favorable rates that individual companies typically cannot negotiate.

ADP

ADP delivers comprehensive benefits administration with plan management for health insurance, retirement accounts, and various supplemental benefits. The platform handles carrier integrations, enrollment workflows, and compliance with ACA, COBRA, and related regulations.

ADP's benefits capabilities are particularly strong for larger organizations with complex benefit structures. The platform offers detailed reporting and analytics on benefits costs, utilization patterns, and trends.

Paylocity

Paylocity provides benefits administration with plan management and enrollment functionality. As an IRS-registered reporting agent, the platform handles benefits-related tax compliance and required filings. Standard benefits like health insurance and retirement plans integrate well.

However, Paylocity's international capabilities are restricted to payroll processing only. The platform doesn't support integrated benefits administration or time-off policies for employees outside the US, which creates complications for companies with global workforces.

Our verdict

All three platforms handle benefits administration, but Rippling's unified architecture eliminates data synchronization issues and enables superior automation. Rippling's PEO access also delivers better benefits rates than ADP or Paylocity can provide to small and mid-sized organizations.

Time & attendance

Accurate time tracking ensures correct payroll calculations and effective labor cost management.

Rippling

Rippling's time & attendance system integrates directly with payroll processing, allowing employees to clock in from any device, track PTO balances, and submit time-off requests within the same platform. The system supports customized overtime rules, break policies, geofencing, project-based time tracking, and automated approval chains based on employee attributes.

Because time data exists in the same database as payroll information, there's no export/import process. Time entries automatically become payroll inputs, eliminating transcription errors and reducing administrative overhead.

ADP

ADP provides comprehensive time and attendance functionality with mobile clock-in options, advanced scheduling tools, and labor cost forecasting. The platform integrates time information with payroll to automate wage calculations and handles sophisticated scenarios like multiple pay rates, job codes, and department transfers.

ADP's time tracking capabilities are particularly robust for businesses with hourly workforces or intricate scheduling demands. However, configuration and setup demand considerable time and technical expertise.

Paylocity

Paylocity delivers time & attendance features with mobile access for employees to log hours and request PTO. The platform handles fundamental timekeeping and connects with payroll for wage processing.

However, Paylocity's time tracking lacks the sophisticated automated workflows and multi-level approval chains that Rippling provides, often requiring more manual oversight.

Our verdict

All three platforms provide comprehensive time & attendance capabilities. Rippling's advantage is the unified data architecture and extensive automation. Time entries, for example, automatically become payroll data once approved without manual steps, preventing sync delays. 

ADP offers strong functionality for complex scenarios, while Paylocity delivers solid capabilities for standard requirements.

Integrations

Integration capabilities determine how effectively your HR software connects with your broader technology ecosystem.

Rippling

Rippling approaches integrations fundamentally differently. Rather than merely connecting to external systems, Rippling provides native HR, IT, and spend management within one unified platform. This eliminates the need for many integrations entirely.

For external applications you do need to connect, Rippling offers 650+ integrations with real-time bidirectional synchronization. When employee data changes in Rippling, it automatically updates across all connected systems instantly — not through scheduled nightly syncs, but in real-time.

ADP

ADP offers 400+ integrations including QuickBooks, Xero, and Workday. The platform connects with accounting systems, benefits carriers, and various third-party applications to extend core functionality.

However, ADP's integrations may depend on scheduled synchronization or manual data exports rather than continuous real-time updates. This can create data consistency challenges when employee information changes between sync intervals.

Paylocity

Paylocity provides 420+ integrations including Bank of America, UnitedHealthcare, and Vanguard through its marketplace. The platform connects with financial institutions, benefits providers, and other HR tools.

Our verdict

Rippling wins because it eliminates the need for most integrations by providing HR, IT, and spend management natively in one platform. For integrations you do need, Rippling's real-time synchronization ensures data consistency across systems. ADP and Paylocity offer substantial integration options but depend on scheduled syncs that can create data timing issues.

ADP vs. Paylocity vs. Rippling: Pricing

Understanding actual costs helps inform your decision.

Rippling

Rippling uses custom pricing based on which modules and features your organization needs. While this requires a sales conversation to get your specific quote, it means you only pay for capabilities you'll actually use.

As a reference point, Rippling's pricing starts at $8 per employee per month for core HRIS functionality, with incremental costs for additional modules including payroll, benefits administration, time & attendance, IT management, and spend management.

The modular pricing model works particularly well for growing businesses. You can start with essential features and add capabilities as you scale without migrating to a different platform.

ADP

ADP employs custom pricing determined by business size, selected services, and customization requirements. The platform offers several product tiers:

• Do It Yourself: Entry-level payroll for very small businesses

• RUN: Full-service payroll and HR for small to mid-sized businesses

• Workforce Now: Comprehensive solution for mid-market and enterprise organizations

ADP's pricing typically sits at a premium compared to alternatives, reflecting its extensive feature set and global infrastructure. You'll need to engage with sales for specific pricing.

Paylocity

Paylocity offers customized payroll and HR packages based on company size and module selection. Like ADP and Rippling, you'll need sales discussions for accurate quotes.

Paylocity's pricing generally targets mid-market businesses with 50+ employees. Costs can be competitive for organizations needing strong HR and payroll capabilities without requiring IT or spend management features.

ADP vs. Paylocity vs. Rippling: Reviews

Verified user feedback reveals how these platforms actually perform in daily operations. Here's how they compare on major review platforms:

What users love about Rippling: Users consistently highlight Rippling's unified platform, powerful automation capabilities, and excellent customer support. Common themes include dramatic time savings through workflows, seamless HR and IT management in one system, and the platform's ability to scale alongside business growth.

What users love about ADP: Users emphasize ADP's comprehensive features, global capabilities, and deep functionality for handling sophisticated HR scenarios. Large enterprises particularly value the platform's ability to manage complex requirements across multiple jurisdictions.

What users love about Paylocity: Users appreciate Paylocity's comprehensive reporting capabilities, solid HR feature set, and dedicated support teams. Mid-sized businesses value the platform's depth for performance management and benefits administration.

What users wish was better:

• Rippling: Some users note the initial learning curve when configuring advanced workflows and the requirement for sales conversations to obtain pricing.

• ADP: Users frequently express frustration with the steep learning curve, overwhelming complexity for smaller teams, and inconsistent customer service responsiveness.

• Paylocity: Some users report customer service can be slow, and that some modules felt too disjointed or separate from others.

Manage your workforce effortlessly

See Rippling

ADP vs. Paylocity vs. Rippling: Pros and cons

Let's examine the specific strengths and limitations of each platform.

Rippling pros and cons

Pros:

• Unified platform across HR, IT, and Finance eliminates data silos and manual synchronization

• Powerful workflow automation delivers significant time savings

• Global payroll capabilities support international expansion seamlessly, with 185+ countries and 90+ currencies

• Comprehensive feature set scales with business growth

• Native integrations ensure data stays synchronized automatically

• Highly rated customer support with dedicated account management

• Advanced cross-platform reporting and analytics

Cons:

• Custom pricing model requires sales conversations

• Extensive feature set creates initial learning curve

ADP pros and cons

Pros:

• Global payroll in 140+ countries with multi-currency support and localized compliance

• Deep functionality for sophisticated HR scenarios

• Strong compliance tools designed for large enterprises

• Extensive features across all HR functions

• Established provider with decades of track record

Cons:

• Steep learning curve with complex interface

• Premium pricing compared to alternatives

• Customer service responsiveness varies according to user feedback

• Can overwhelm smaller organizations without dedicated HR teams

Paylocity pros and cons

Pros:

• Strong HR and payroll features targeting mid-market companies

• Solid performance management and talent tools

• Comprehensive benefits administration capabilities

• Full LMS functionality

• Dedicated customer support teams

Cons:

• Lacks unified data architecture, relying on synced modules

• Limited automation in key areas like LMS training assignments

• International capabilities restricted to payroll only

Rippling: The smarter alternative to ADP and Paylocity

After evaluating all three platforms, Rippling stands out as the most comprehensive solution for growing businesses. Here's why.

Unified architecture, not just integrations

While ADP and Paylocity connect to other tools through integrations, Rippling is architecturally different. It operates as a unified platform where employee data exists in one system of record and automatically flows to HR, IT, Finance, and every connected application.

This fundamental difference means when you update an employee's role, location, or department, that change instantaneously propagates everywhere — app access, device permissions, payroll calculations, benefits eligibility, and more. No manual updates across systems. No data synchronization delays. No reconciling conflicting information.

Designed for growth without migration pain

ADP serves large enterprises with complex needs and substantial implementation resources. Paylocity targets mid-market businesses focused primarily on HR and payroll functions. Both require significant upfront investment and can be challenging to grow with.

Rippling is architected for scalability. Start with core HR and payroll, then add capabilities like learning management, performance reviews, IT infrastructure management, or global payroll as your needs evolve — without migrating platforms or managing complicated integrations.

Automation that delivers measurable time savings

All three platforms promise efficiency gains, but Rippling delivers through extensive workflow automation that ADP and Paylocity cannot match.

Rippling's Workflow Studio enables you to automate virtually any process based on employee attributes, custom fields, or specific triggers. Organizations using Rippling consistently report reclaiming 50% or more of time previously spent on HR and IT tasks.

Beyond HR: Complete business operations platform

ADP and Paylocity concentrate on HR and payroll. Rippling extends further by incorporating native IT management and spend management within the same unified platform.

This means you manage not just employee HR information and payroll, but also their devices, application access, and company spending — all from one system. This proves particularly valuable for growing businesses requiring operational efficiency spanning multiple departments.

Get started with a platform that truly unifies your operations.

Put HR busywork on autopilot

See Rippling

FAQs about Paylocity vs. ADP vs. Rippling